Guess the Footballer
Somebody from a pool of 895 players has been picked. Name any player and the row that comes back compares them with the answer: nationality, league, club, position and year of birth. You have 8 guesses to close in.
- Same as the answer.
- Close. The answer comes from the same confederation, also played in that league or for that club, plays next to that position, or was born within two years of that one.
- ↑The answer was born later. ↓ means earlier.
How the columns work
What do the colours mean on each column?
›
Green is an exact match. Yellow is close, and close has a fixed meaning for each column. On Nat it means the same confederation, so a French guess against a Croatian answer is yellow because both are UEFA. On League and Club it means the answer also played in the league or for the club shown. On Pos it means the next position along the line from defence to attack: defender, midfielder, winger, forward. On Born it means a birth year within two of the answer's. Grey means none of that applies.
Which way do the arrows point?
›
Toward the answer. An up arrow on the birth year means the answer was born later than your guess, a down arrow that they were born earlier. The arrow stays on a yellow cell too, so a yellow 1985 with an up arrow means 1986 or 1987.
How do the League and Club columns decide what to show?
›
If your guess and the answer are at the same club now, or finished their careers at the same club, the Club cell is green. If not, it lists every club in your guess's career that the answer also played for, newest first, in yellow, so a Cristiano Ronaldo guess against an answer who played for Manchester United and Real Madrid shows both. Only if there is no shared club at all does it show your guess's latest club in grey. League works the same way with the leagues those clubs play in, so a yellow always names everything worth chasing.
Which league does a club count as?
›
The top flight of the country it plays in, by the name fans use: Premier League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1, MLS and so on. Monaco counts as Ligue 1, Cardiff and Swansea as the Premier League and Toronto as MLS, because that is where they play.
Why a birth year and not an age?
›
Because most of the pool has retired and some of it has died. An age would put Pelé in his eighties years after his death, and it would change every January. A birth year means the same thing for Lamine Yamal and for Puskás, and it places a player in their generation, which is what the clue is for.
Who is in the pool?
›
895 players, all of them people a football fan would recognise. 492 have played in the last decade, 353 are from roughly 1990 to 2015, and 50 played before that, from Di Stéfano and Puskás to Maradona and Van Basten. It is the same list the Football Wordle uses.
Can I guess a player who is not in the pool?
›
No. The search box only offers players from the pool, because every guess has to be comparable on all five columns. A name it cannot find is a name the answer cannot be, so you never waste a guess on someone outside it. Accents are optional when you type: mbappe finds Mbappé and odegaard finds Ødegaard.
What happens when a player changes club?
›
The clubs are the ones on the shared football list this site uses for all its football games, so a transfer gets fixed in one place and every game picks it up, the League column included. Until then both columns use the club on record. There is no shirt number column for the same reason: numbers change with every transfer, and a clue that is out of date is worse than none.
Does choosing an era make it easier?
›
It narrows who the answer can be, and if you pick the era you watched, yes. It does not narrow the search box. You can guess anybody in the pool whatever era you picked, because a Golden player's row still tells you about leagues, clubs and nationality in a Modern round. Classic is the smallest era at 50 names, and 7 of them share no club with any other Classic player, so guessing other legends tells you nothing about where those 7 played.
Is there a daily player?
›
No. A player is drawn when you press Start and another when you press Next, so you can play as many as you like in one sitting. A session works through the pool without repeats until it runs out.
The best first guess, worked out
Every guess splits the 895 possible answers into groups: all the players who would have given you exactly the row you got back. A good opener leaves you in a small group. Run every player in the pool as a first guess against every possible answer and you can put a number on it, the average size of the group you end up in.
Juan Mata comes out on top. One guess leaves about 13.1 players on average, out of 895. The names near the top have a lot in common. They played for several of the big clubs in more than one of the big leagues, they are European, and they were born close to 1988, the middle of the pool. That gives every column a fair chance of coming back yellow, and yellow is what narrows things down.
| OPENER | PLAYERS LEFT |
|---|---|
| Juan Mata | 13.1 |
| Samir Nasri | 14.3 |
| Thiago Alcântara | 14.4 |
| Jordan Henderson | 15.2 |
| Sami Khedira | 16.0 |
| Kieran Trippier | 16.3 |
The worst openers are Jorge Campos, Lev Yashin and Helmuth Duckadam, each leaving 396 or more players on average. They played for clubs few others in the pool touched, or in a position with no neighbours, so most of the row comes back grey and grey only rules things out one at a time. With 8 guesses you can afford one of those, but not as your first.
Which clubs are worth a yellow
A yellow club means the answer played there at some point. How much that tells you depends on the club. Most of the pool has been through one of a few giants, so a yellow Barcelona still leaves dozens of people, while 78 of the 253 clubs in the pool belong to one player only, and a yellow on one of those nearly gives the answer away. These are the clubs the most players in the pool have passed through:
- Barcelona104 · 12%
- Chelsea101 · 11%
- Real Madrid99 · 11%
- Manchester United98 · 11%
- Arsenal93 · 10%
- Inter Milan92 · 10%
- Liverpool87 · 10%
- Juventus83 · 9%
Green on the club column is harder to get than it looks. It means both players’ latest clubs are the same, so for retired players it compares where they finished, not where they were famous. A yellow lists every club the two careers share, newest first, so when a guess played for Ajax, Barcelona and Milan and the answer played for Ajax and Milan, the cell shows Milan and Ajax and leaves Barcelona out.
Why a yellow flag is weak in Europe
Yellow on the nationality column means the same confederation, and the pool is not spread evenly across them. 630 of the 895 players are European, so a European guess that comes back yellow has ruled out only the other 30% of the field. The same yellow on a Moroccan or a Korean guess cuts the pool to a handful at once.
- UEFA630 · Europe
- CONMEBOL159 · South America
- CAF60 · Africa
- CONCACAF23 · North and Central America
- AFC23 · Asia and Australia
The league column is a blunt first cut
A green league means the answer finished in the same league as your guess, a yellow one that they played in it at some point. The pool leans hard on a handful of leagues, so a yellow Premier League or La Liga still leaves a crowd, while a green on a smaller league nearly names the answer. These are the leagues the most players in the pool have played in:
| LEAGUE | EVER PLAYED | FINISHED THERE |
|---|---|---|
| Premier League | 533 · 60% | 287 |
| Serie A | 338 · 38% | 172 |
| La Liga | 294 · 33% | 123 |
| Ligue 1 | 178 · 20% | 50 |
| Bundesliga | 171 · 19% | 51 |
| Eredivisie | 79 · 9% | 10 |
| Primeira Liga | 65 · 7% | 9 |
| Süper Lig | 60 · 7% | 40 |